Motion for Reconsideration in Federal Court: Rule 59(e) vs. Rule 60(b)
The judge ruled against you, and you think they got it wrong. Can you ask them to look again? Sometimes. This guide explains the three ways to ask, the hard deadlines for each, and the one mistake that can cost you your appeal. It also tells you the honest truth: these motions are rarely granted.
The honest truth about reconsideration
A motion for reconsideration asks the same judge to change their own ruling. That is a hard ask. The judge already read the papers and decided.
There isn't one single "reconsideration" rule. Instead, a few different rules let you ask for a second look, each with its own purpose and deadline. The Supreme Court has said that, under Rule 59(e), courts will not consider new arguments or evidence you could have raised before the decision (Banister v. Davis, 590 U.S. 504 (2020)).
Sometimes the better path is an appeal, where a different court reviews the ruling. Sometimes it is both: a short motion first, then an appeal if it fails. Either way, the deadlines below decide what is still possible, so read them before you choose.
That doesn't mean you should never file one. If the judge truly missed something, or new facts came to light, it may be worth it. Just go in with clear eyes. For more on how judges handle filings from people without lawyers, see how judges actually treat pro se litigants.
First: what kind of ruling did you get?
The right rule depends on whether the ruling ended your case.
- A final judgment ends the case (or the whole case against a party), usually as a separate document titled "Judgment." Rules 59(e) and 60(b) apply.
- An interlocutory order is a ruling made in the middle of the case. "Interlocutory" just means "in between." Examples: denying a motion to compel, dismissing one claim while others go on, or striking a filing. These fall under Rule 54(b) and your court's local rules.
Not sure which you have? Look at the docket on PACER. Check whether a separate "Judgment" entry was filed, and whether any claims or parties are still left in the case.
Track 1: Orders in the middle of a case
Under FRCP 54(b), an order that decides fewer than all the claims or parties doesn't end the case. The judge may revise it any time before final judgment. That is the basic power you are asking the judge to use.
Your district may have a local rule on motions to reconsider these orders. A local rule like that may set a deadline, list the reasons that count, limit length, or require permission before you file. Look up your district's local rules and your judge's standing orders before you write a word.
Search your court's local rules for "reconsideration." If nothing comes up, check the judge's page on the court website, then call the clerk's office and ask where the procedure is written down.
Track 2: Rule 59(e) — change the judgment
FRCP 59(e) lets you ask the court to "alter or amend" a judgment. The motion must be filed no later than 28 days after the judgment is entered. "Entered" means the date it was put on the docket, not the date you received it.
This deadline is strict. Under FRCP 6(b)(2), the court must not extend the time to act under Rule 59(e). A motion for more time won't help. If you need more time to write, file a shorter motion on time.
In Banister v. Davis, the Supreme Court described Rule 59(e) as a way for a judge to fix their own mistakes in the short period right after a judgment. That makes it the place to point out a real error, or evidence that truly wasn't available before. It is not the place for new theories you could have raised earlier.
Track 3: Rule 60(b) — relief from a judgment or order
FRCP 60(b) lists six reasons the court may relieve a party from a final judgment or order. In plain words:
- Mistake or excusable neglect — mistake, inadvertence, surprise, or excusable neglect.
- New evidence — evidence that you couldn't have found in time for a Rule 59(b) motion, even trying hard.
- Fraud or misconduct by the other side, including misrepresentation.
- The judgment is void — for example, the court had no power to enter it.
- The judgment was satisfied or is outdated — it was paid or released, was based on an earlier judgment that was reversed, or applying it going forward is no longer fair.
- Any other reason that justifies relief — a catch-all for unusual situations.
Timing is in Rule 60(c)(1). Every 60(b) motion must be made "within a reasonable time." For reasons 1, 2, and 3, it must also be filed no more than one year after the judgment or order. Like Rule 59(e), the court cannot extend this time (FRCP 6(b)(2)).
Under Rule 60(c)(2), filing a 60(b) motion does not stop the judgment from being final or from taking effect.
Rule 59(e) vs. Rule 60(b) side by side
| Question | Rule 59(e) | Rule 60(b) |
|---|---|---|
| What it asks for | Alter or amend the judgment | Relief from a final judgment or order |
| Deadline | 28 days after entry of judgment | Reasonable time; 1-year outer limit for reasons 1–3 |
| Can the court extend it? | No (FRCP 6(b)(2)) | No (FRCP 6(b)(2)) |
| Typical use | Clear error, or new evidence, soon after judgment | The six listed reasons, including fraud and void judgments |
| Effect on appeal deadline | Timely motion resets it (FRAP 4(a)(4)(A)(iv)) | Resets it only if filed within 28 days of judgment (FRAP 4(a)(4)(A)(vi)) |
Don't lose your appeal
This is the part that ends cases. In most civil cases, a notice of appeal is due 30 days after the judgment is entered, or 60 days if the United States or a federal agency or officer is a party (FRAP 4(a)(1)).
Under FRAP 4(a)(4)(A), some motions reset that clock if filed on time. Among them are a Rule 59 motion to alter or amend the judgment, and a Rule 60 motion filed within 28 days after judgment. Then the appeal time runs from the order that decides the last of those motions.
A Rule 60(b) motion filed more than 28 days after judgment does not pause your appeal deadline. The 30-day (or 60-day) clock keeps running. If you want to appeal and file a late 60(b) motion, you may need to file the notice of appeal anyway. And if you appeal after the judge rules on your motion, FRAP 4(a)(4)(B)(ii) says you may need a new or amended notice of appeal to challenge that ruling. When in doubt, read FRAP 4 yourself and ask your court's pro se help desk about the procedure.
The full appeal process is in how to file a pro se appeal in federal court.
How to write and file the motion
- Name the rule in the title. For example: "Plaintiff's Motion to Alter or Amend Judgment Under Fed. R. Civ. P. 59(e)." The rule controls the deadline and the standard, so be clear.
- Say exactly what was wrong. Quote or cite the page of the order. Explain the error in a few sentences. Don't re-argue the whole case.
- Show new evidence the right way. Attach it as an exhibit with a declaration explaining what it is and why you couldn't get it sooner.
- Ask for a specific result. For example: "vacate the judgment and reopen the case," or "amend the judgment to correct the amount."
- Follow local formatting. Page limits, fonts, and conference requirements vary. Our formatting guide covers the basics.
- File early and serve. Don't wait for day 28. Add a certificate of service.
Mistakes to avoid
- Repeating your old brief. If the judge already considered an argument, saying it louder won't help.
- Blaming or attacking the judge. Stay respectful. Focus on the error, not the person.
- Skipping local steps. Some courts require you to contact the other side first, or to ask permission before filing. Check.
- Calling it the wrong thing. A title like "Objection" or "Appeal to the Judge" leaves the court guessing which rule you mean. Name the rule.
- Waiting on the motion and missing the appeal. Track both deadlines on a calendar from the day the judgment is entered.
These deadlines are short. Get your motion and supporting exhibits built and size-checked fast. ECF PDF combines your pages, adds exhibit cover sheets and page numbers, and warns you about locked files or files over your court's limit. Free, and your files stay on your device.
Open the free tool →Knowing your basic rights in court can help you stay calm through this. See rights of pro se litigants in federal court, and avoid the traps in pro se mistakes that get federal cases dismissed.
Common questions
How long do I have to file a motion for reconsideration in federal court?
It depends on the rule. A Rule 59(e) motion is due 28 days after the judgment is entered. A Rule 60(b) motion must be filed within a reasonable time, and no more than one year for mistake, new evidence, or fraud. Motions about orders in the middle of a case usually follow your court's local rules.
Can I get an extension to file a Rule 59(e) motion?
No. Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 6(b)(2) says the court must not extend the time to act under Rule 59(e) or Rule 60(b). File on time, even if the motion is shorter than you'd like.
Does a motion for reconsideration stop my appeal deadline?
A timely Rule 59 motion does, and so does a Rule 60 motion filed within 28 days after judgment, under FRAP 4(a)(4). A Rule 60(b) motion filed later does not, so the 30-day or 60-day appeal clock keeps running.
Can I raise new arguments in a motion for reconsideration?
Usually not. For Rule 59(e), the Supreme Court has said courts will not consider new arguments or evidence that could have been raised before the decision. These motions are meant for real errors, truly new evidence, or the specific reasons listed in the rules.
How often are motions for reconsideration granted?
Rarely. Judges see them as an exception, not a second round. File one when you can point to a specific error or new evidence, and protect your appeal deadline either way.
Beat the short deadline
Build your motion and exhibits into clean, numbered PDFs, with cover sheets and a size check against your court's limit. Free, no account, and nothing is uploaded.
Keep reading
Sources
- Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 59 — LII
- Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 60 — LII
- Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 6(b)(2) — LII
- Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 54(b) — LII
- Federal Rule of Appellate Procedure 4 — LII
- Banister v. Davis, 590 U.S. 504 (2020) — Justia
Not legal advice. This guide explains general federal court procedure in plain English. Rules change, and your court's local rules and your judge's orders control. ECF PDF is an independent tool and is not affiliated with any court or with PACER. If you can, talk to a lawyer, a law school clinic, or your court's pro se help desk about your case.