How to Ask the Court for a Lawyer: Motion to Appoint Counsel
In most civil cases, you have no right to a free lawyer. But you can ask the judge to find one for you. This guide explains the law behind that request, what judges look at, how to show you tried to find a lawyer on your own, and how to write the motion. It's also honest about the odds: these motions are often denied, especially early in a case.
No right to a lawyer, but you can ask
Civil cases work differently from criminal cases. If you sue someone, or someone sues you, the court usually doesn't have to give you a lawyer. Our guide on the rights of pro se litigants explains this in more detail. ("Pro se" means representing yourself.)
What you can do is file a motion to appoint counsel. That is a written request asking the judge to find a volunteer lawyer for you. Courts sometimes call it a "motion for appointment of counsel" or a "request for counsel." Check your court's website for a form before you write one from scratch.
The law behind the request
The main law is 28 U.S.C. § 1915(e)(1). It says the court "may request an attorney to represent any person unable to afford counsel." Two words matter here.
- "May." The judge has a choice. Nothing requires them to say yes.
- "Request." The judge can ask a lawyer to help. In Mallard v. United States District Court for the Southern District of Iowa, 490 U.S. 296 (1989), the Supreme Court held that this law does not let a federal court force an unwilling lawyer to take a case.
So even when a judge grants your motion, it means the court will try to find a volunteer, such as through a pro bono panel if your court has one. ("Pro bono" means free, for the public good.) If no one agrees, you may still be on your own.
This law is part of the same statute that covers in forma pauperis (IFP) status, which lets people who can't afford court fees proceed without paying up front. If you haven't applied, read how to waive federal filing fees and what IFP actually covers. Your IFP paperwork helps show you can't afford a lawyer.
What judges look at
Each federal circuit has its own test, and judges have wide discretion. But most look at similar questions:
| Question | What helps you show it |
|---|---|
| Can you afford a lawyer? | An approved IFP application, or a declaration about your income and costs |
| Did you try to find one yourself? | A list of every lawyer and group you contacted, with dates and answers |
| Does your claim have some merit? | A case that has survived screening or a motion to dismiss |
| How complex is the case? | Specific issues like medical proof, expert witnesses, or many defendants |
| Can you investigate and present it? | Concrete limits: no access to records or witnesses, limited reading or English, a disability, or prison conditions |
Here is one real example. In the Seventh Circuit, Pruitt v. Mote, 503 F.3d 647 (7th Cir. 2007) (en banc), says the judge asks two questions. First, has the person made a reasonable attempt to get a lawyer, or been effectively blocked from trying? Second, given how hard the case is, does the person seem able to handle it alone? If you are in a different circuit, look up your own circuit's standard on CourtListener before you cite one. Our CourtListener guide shows how.
"I am not a lawyer" or "the case is complicated" is true for almost everyone, so it rarely moves a judge. Explain what you can't do in this case, and why.
Show you tried to find a lawyer
This is the part you control most. Before you file, contact several lawyers and organizations, and keep a record of every one.
- Legal aid offices near you. Search LawHelp.org by state.
- Your state or local bar association's lawyer referral service.
- Law school clinics that handle your type of case.
- Private lawyers who take your type of case, including ones who work for a share of any recovery.
- Your court's pro se or pro bono program. Many districts list them on their website.
Write down each contact: the name, the date, how you reached them, and what they said. Save every letter, email, and rejection. Then attach them to your motion as exhibits. Our exhibit formatting guide covers labeling.
Attach your lawyer-search letters and emails as exhibits and build one clean PDF. ECF PDF combines photos of letters, screenshots of emails, and PDFs, adds an exhibit cover sheet and page numbers, and checks the size. Your files never leave your device.
Open the free tool →Employment discrimination cases: Title VII's own rule
If you are suing for job discrimination under Title VII, there is a second law to cite. Under 42 U.S.C. § 2000e-5(f)(1), when you apply, and in circumstances the court finds just, "the court may appoint an attorney" for you. The same sentence also lets the court allow the case to go forward without paying fees, costs, or security.
It is still up to the judge. Your EEOC file and right-to-sue letter often come up in these requests, so keep them handy. For more, see EEOC right-to-sue letters: the pro se playbook.
How to write the motion
Keep it short and factual. Check your court's local rules for format, and use the court's form if one exists.
- Use the case caption. Court name, parties, and case number at the top, like your other filings.
- Say what you want and the law. One sentence: you ask the court to request counsel under 28 U.S.C. § 1915(e)(1) (and § 2000e-5(f)(1) for Title VII).
- Show you can't afford a lawyer. Point to your IFP status, or attach a declaration.
- List your search. Who you contacted, when, and what they said. Attach proof.
- Explain your specific limits. Why this case is hard for you to handle alone.
- Sign a declaration under penalty of perjury (28 U.S.C. § 1746), and add a certificate of service if the other side has appeared.
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
[DISTRICT] OF [STATE]
[Your Name], )
Plaintiff, ) Case No. [Case No.]
v. )
[Defendant Name], )
Defendant. )
PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR APPOINTMENT OF COUNSEL
Plaintiff [Your Name], proceeding pro se, asks the Court to request an attorney to represent Plaintiff under 28 U.S.C. § 1915(e)(1).
1. Plaintiff cannot afford a lawyer. [The Court granted in forma pauperis status on [date] (ECF No. [__]).]
2. Plaintiff tried to find a lawyer. Plaintiff contacted [number] lawyers and organizations, listed in Exhibit A. [Each declined / did not respond.]
3. This case is difficult for Plaintiff to present alone because [specific reasons: e.g., the claims require medical records Plaintiff cannot obtain; Plaintiff has limited access to a law library].
For these reasons, Plaintiff asks the Court to request counsel to represent Plaintiff.
Dated: [date]
/s/ [Your Name]
[Your Name], Pro Se
[Address] | [Phone] | [Email]What to leave out
- Your whole case. A short summary of your claims is enough. The judge can read the complaint.
- Complaints about the other side's lawyers. Stick to why you need help.
- Private details. Keep Social Security numbers, birth dates, and account numbers out, as FRCP 5.2 requires. If medical or other sensitive facts matter, ask your court how to file them under seal.
If the judge says no
Expect this possibility. Judges often deny early requests, before the facts are developed. A denial may say it is "without prejudice." That means you are allowed to ask again later.
- Read the order closely. It often says what was missing, such as too few lawyer contacts.
- Keep working your case. Meet every deadline. A denial does not pause anything.
- Ask again when things change. Good times are after you survive a motion to dismiss or summary judgment, or before trial. Explain what is new.
- Keep looking for help. Keep contacting clinics and legal aid, and ask about limited help such as advice on a single motion.
It also helps to know how judges actually treat pro se litigants, so you know what to expect while you represent yourself.
Common questions
Do I have a right to a free lawyer in a federal civil case?
Usually not. In most civil cases, the court doesn't have to give you a lawyer. Instead, the court may request a lawyer for someone who can't afford one under 28 U.S.C. § 1915(e)(1), but it is up to the judge.
Can a federal judge make a lawyer take my case?
No. In Mallard v. United States District Court, 490 U.S. 296 (1989), the Supreme Court held that § 1915 lets courts request, not require, a lawyer to represent someone. Courts usually look for volunteers, often through pro bono panels.
How many lawyers should I contact before I file?
No federal rule sets a number. Contact several lawyers and organizations that handle your type of case, write down each contact and response, and attach your records. Check your circuit's cases and your court's local rules for what judges there expect.
When is the best time to file a motion to appoint counsel?
You can file at any time, but judges often deny early requests before the facts are developed. If you are denied, you can usually ask again later, for example after your case survives a motion to dismiss or before trial.
Is there a special rule for employment discrimination cases?
Yes. For Title VII cases, 42 U.S.C. § 2000e-5(f)(1) lets the court appoint an attorney upon your application, in circumstances the court finds just. It is still up to the judge.
Build your motion and exhibits
Turn your lawyer-search letters, emails, and IFP papers into one clean PDF with an exhibit cover sheet and page numbers. Free, no account, and nothing is uploaded.
Keep reading
Sources
- 28 U.S.C. § 1915 (proceedings in forma pauperis) — LII
- Mallard v. U.S. District Court, 490 U.S. 296 (1989) — Justia
- Walker v. Price (7th Cir. 2018), quoting Pruitt v. Mote, 503 F.3d 647 (7th Cir. 2007) (en banc) — FindLaw
- 42 U.S.C. § 2000e-5 (Title VII enforcement) — LII
- 28 U.S.C. § 1746 (declarations under penalty of perjury) — LII
Not legal advice. This guide explains general federal court procedure in plain English. Rules change, and your court's local rules and your judge's orders control. ECF PDF is an independent tool and is not affiliated with any court or with PACER. If you can, talk to a lawyer, a law school clinic, or your court's pro se help desk about your case.